Skip to content

Boston Rye

Whiskey reviews and musings

  • Home
  • All Reviews
  • Reviews by Rating

Tag: Signatory Vintage

Glenrothes

Glenrothes 20 Year SV Cask Strength 1997 54.5%

July 26, 2021June 8, 2025 bostonrye
Caol Ila

Caol Ila 12 Year SV Cask Strength 2006 56.7%

April 20, 2021June 8, 2025 bostonrye
Deanston

Deanston 11 Year SV Cask Strength 2008 66.7%

November 17, 2020October 3, 2021 bostonrye

Recent Reviews

  • Thompson Brothers Isle of Jura 34 Year (1989)
  • Archives Glenburgie 1995 21 Year
  • Rabbit Hole Founder’s Collection Cask Strength Boxergrail Rye 8 Year (2nd Release)
  • Lot 40 Rye Whiskey (2012 Release)
  • Shelter Point Single Cask Triple Grain

Rating Breakdown

  1 – 19 | Disgusting | Drain pour

20 – 29 | Poor | Forced myself to drink it

30 – 39 | Bad | Multiple flaws

40 – 49 | Sub-par | Many things I’d rather have

50 – 59 | Average | Solid, ordinary

60 – 69 | Good | Better than average

70 – 79 | Great | Well above average

80 – 89 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional

90 – 99 | Incredible | An all time favorite

      100 | Perfect | Nothing else comes close

  • instagram
  • mail
  • reddit

Reviews by Distillery

  • Aberlour (1)
  • Alberta Distillers (2)
  • Angel's Envy (1)
  • Ardbeg (1)
  • B.R. Distilling (1)
  • Balvenie (1)
  • Barrell (6)
  • Black Velvet (1)
  • Broken Barrel (1)
  • Buffalo Trace (7)
  • Bulleit (1)
  • Bunnahabhain (2)
  • Buzzard's Roost (1)
  • Caol Ila (1)
  • Chicken Cock (1)
  • Clark & Chesterfield (1)
  • Cooper Spirits (3)
  • Copper & Cask (1)
  • Crown Royal (1)
  • Deanston (1)
  • Driftless Glen (1)
  • Famous Grouse (1)
  • Found North (1)
  • Four Roses (3)
  • Frey Ranch (1)
  • Glen Moray (1)
  • Glenburgie (1)
  • Glendronach (1)
  • Glengoyne (1)
  • Glenlivet (1)
  • Glenmorangie (1)
  • Glenrothes (1)
  • Good Times (1)
  • Grangestone (1)
  • Heaven Hill (2)
  • High West (3)
  • Hiram Walker (7)
  • Jack Daniel's (1)
  • James E. Pepper (1)
  • Jim Beam (2)
  • Jura (1)
  • Keeper's Heart (1)
  • Kentucky Owl (1)
  • Kozuba (1)
  • Lagavulin (1)
  • Longrow (1)
  • Luxco (1)
  • Maker's Mark (1)
  • Mammoth (1)
  • Michter's (3)
  • Montgomery Distillery (1)
  • Nashville Barrel Co. (2)
  • Nelson's Green Brier (1)
  • New Riff (3)
  • Nikka (1)
  • O.H. Ingram (1)
  • Oceanside Distillers (1)
  • Old Potrero (2)
  • Penelope (2)
  • Proof & Wood (3)
  • Rabbit Hole (2)
  • Rare Character (1)
  • Redbreast (1)
  • Redemption (2)
  • Shelter Point (3)
  • Smoke Wagon (2)
  • Smooth Ambler (1)
  • Springbank (3)
  • Stellum (2)
  • Talisker (1)
  • Traverse City Whiskey Co. (2)
  • Treaty Oak (2)
  • Uncle Nearest (1)
  • WhistlePig (3)
  • Willett (2)
Copyright © 2021 Boston Rye. All rights reserved.
Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Fairy by Candid Themes.